X

Thanksgiving Dinner in Stonington Borough

Thanksgiving Dinner in Stonington Borough

Where to Eat When You’re Staying at the Inn at Stonington

Thanksgiving Dinner in Stonington Borough

Every November we drive the same quiet stretch of Route 1, park once, and do not touch the car again until Sunday.

Late fall in Stonington Borough runs on woodsmoke, bare masts and four-thirty sunsets.

Then there is the Inn at Stonington, eighteen rooms set directly on the harbor, which is the most romantic address on the Connecticut shoreline.

“We booked a Sea Side room; eight of them face the harbor and Fishers Island Sound, while the Village Side rooms look over rooftops.

Ours came with a gas fireplace, a soaking tub deep enough to vanish into, and a balcony holding exactly two chairs.

It is unapologetically romantic, the kind of room that makes you cancel your own plans.

Two chairs on that balcony at dusk are the most romantic square footage in the village.”

Then comes the question everyone asks: where do you actually eat on the day itself?

In a village this small, the answer takes a phone call, and it turns out to be the most romantic three days we take all year.

Thursday, November 26, is the date to plan around.

Dog Watch Cafe at 194 Water Street is the most dependable holiday option in the Borough, and its feast is takeout rather than table service.

The last published package ran to house-smoked or oven-roasted turkey, traditional stuffing, pan gravy and a choice of sides, including sweet potato pecan casserole, green bean casserole, and balsamic roasted Brussels sprouts with crispy bacon.

Small packages were $150 and large $225, collected from the Dog Watch kitchen in Mystic. Call 860-415-4510 early to confirm this year’s menu and pickup window.

Eaten at a candlelit table upstairs, it absolutely counts.

Noah’s at 113 Water Street and Breakwater at 66 Water Street stay open through the holiday stretch, though neither advertises a Thanksgiving menu or confirmed holiday hours, so call ahead.

We move both to Friday and Saturday: Noah’s for chef-owned scratch cooking and local seafood, Breakwater for harbor sunsets and a bar that stays warm in November.

Breakfast is a short walk too, and the shopping district is three streets wide, the correct size for a holiday weekend.

The Portugese Holy Ghost Society opens to the public for their annual Thanksgiving 4 hour breakfast.

One warning. Water Street Cafe has announced a final service on November 7, 2026, after three decades in the village, so it will not be an option this year.

What makes the weekend work is proximity.

Dinner is a six-minute walk and the walk home takes longer, because the harbor turns silver and the streets empty, and a slow stroll through a sleeping village beats any reservation.

It is romantic precisely because you never once have to drive.

Mornings are the part we never photograph and always remember: coffee, harbor light, nowhere to be, nothing open yet.

A romantic Thanksgiving here does not require a parade.

Book the table before the room, and both before you book travel.

The Inn at Stonington, rated as the most romantic inn along the New England shoreline, fills early for the holiday, and eighteen rooms keep the building hushed.

That is the whole trick: romantic by architecture rather than by marketing, and quietly, unfailingly romantic once the crowds have gone home.

Pack one good sweater and nothing formal.

See you over Thanksgiving…

Your hosts at the Inn at Stonington, Sue, Stephanie, and Bill

860.535.2000

Winter Ocean Weekends

At the Inn at Stonington, draw a sense of calm from the in-room gas fireplaces and soaking tubs—or, if excitement's what you're after, just step out the front door.

Yankee Magazine - January | February 2017
WINE DAYTRIPS: CONNECTICUT

Go all out and book a romantic night or two at the elegant eighteen-room Inn at Stonington on the waterfront, where you’ll be in walking distance of shops, galleries and eateries.

Rhode Island Monthly
'Connecticut Magazine'

"Like a piece of Nantucket that's somehow broken off and drifted southwest."

Connecticut Magazine